THERE HAS BEEN MANY COMMENTS ON THIS BLOG- I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE IT CLEAR, AS THE TITLE SUGGESTS, THIS IS AN OPINION BLOG. I AM EXPLAINING, FOR THE BENEFIT OF FRIENDS WHO WISH TO TRAVEL TO JAPAN FOR CONS ALONE, WHY THEY MAY WANT TO RETHINK THIS. I AM NOT TRYING TO STATE JAPANESE CONS ARE INFERIOR/WORSE THAN WESTERN CONS. ^^;
Long title, I know. And I’m sure anyone reading this must think I’m mad. How can the UK be better than Japan, the place where anime, cosplay and eventually conventions first came to be?
Trust me when I say I still can’t believe it myself. I went to Japan with high hopes of cosplaying all the time, having access to millions of anime/manga merch and attending many conventions.
Unfortunately, this never came to light. Maybe because I didn’t live in Tokyo and don’t speak fluent Japanese, so I was out of the loop a lot. But I certainly never saw any cons advertised.
Before I begin my comparison, I have to admit I am not regarded a massive con goer even in my home land. I attended Auichinawa once, Dee-con and recently the MCM Expo in Glasgow. However, I used to cosplay a lot when I went to Nanashi Dansu, which used to run every month.
The format of most UK conventions are the same: some sort of dealer area where official merch is sold; homegrown talent selling local comics and goods; some sort of photo booth/ place where you can have professional photographs taken. Then, within the event, there will be a schedule, such as voice actor panels, a cosplay masquerade/competition and sometimes ending with a disco/pub quiz.
UK conventions are pretty straightforward- you turn up with your pre-paid ticket/pay at the door, and go have fun. In Japan, it’s a little different.
I attended the Tokyo Game Show, which is mainly aimed at gamers as the name suggests, and Comiket, the biggest cosplay/comic convention in Japan.
For both events, there was a massive queue. We got early tickets for TGS but Comiket was free so you could walk in (or battle the crowds in).
The main difference (apart from the scale of these events, which is about 10 x the size of the events in the UK) is that you CANNOT walk into an event in cosplay.
The is a big problem for many reasons. First, it’s hard enough putting on your wig, make up, costume and props and getting to an event, never mind having to transport all this to a con and then change there. To make it worse, the “changing room” is a big open room, with nothing to shield you when you are changing. Of course it’s separated by gender, but this can be a nightmare for those who have to often change into underwear (or lack of) for their costume. Also, there are NO mirrors, so unless you have your own, you cannot even tell how you look once you change until you leave the area and manage to find a bathroom (where it is forbidden to change into cosplay). To top it all off, you need to register and PAY to cosplay, and wear a stupid sticker to prove it.
There will usually be a place to store your luggage, but the technicalities of trying to reassemble a cosplay in a room full of strangers with no mirror is a nightmare.
This is issue number one.
Issue number two is photographs are usually restricted to the “Cosplay Area”. While it’s great to have a dedicated area to take pictures, it means if you see someone outwith the area you want to take a picture with or of, you can’t. For me, this destroys one of the main enjoyments of a convention- walking around admiring costumes, talking pictures or having others asking if they can take your photo.
Also, once in the cosplay area, it is very common to be surrounded by Otaku wielding big Nikkon cameras. While they are polite and flattering, you can end up trapped for hours in one place.
The next issue is the main one. We are so used to the format of UK conventions, I assumed they replicated the Japanese model. This may be the case, but not any Japanese convention I seen or heard of.
TGS was impressive in terms of the displays by all the big names like Konami, Sega etc. However there was very little merch to actually buy. Most of it was just displaying graphics.
Comiket was not at all what I expected. It was massive, with 100,000 attendees. There were lots of great cosplays, but I have to admit I didn’t recognise half of them, not up to date with Japanese anime due to my lack of fluency and crap TV.
The main problem was there were no signs or maps in English and the scale of Comiket was indescribable. Even compared to London Expo, Comiket would be about 5 x bigger. Sounds amazing I know, but this was not the case.
I arrived at 11am on the Sunday and was able to walk (wade) right in. Maybe the Saturday was for the official dealers, but I doubt it. Comiket is mainly a collection of manga-ka trying to sell their work. However, they are not the famous ones we know. There were about 2 massive halls dedicated to hentai alone. This was not mild, skirt lifting panty stuff. This was full on, xxx rated hardcore porn. The stalls had massive posters displaying their art. Don’t get me wrong, there were many women selling their work in these halls too. However I felt it was mainly aimed towards the male audience looking for, simply, big breasts.
After about two hours of this wandering around I found some non hentai doushinji artworks (people that make fan work of famous manga/anime) but there was again, nothing I recognised.
I managed to purchase a small pin of Hunter x Hunter and Yu Yu Hakusho chibis. There were some stalls selling steam punk and jewellery, but these were few. I bought a pair of white clip in cat ears there.
The next two halls were dedicated to yaoi, something I haven’t been interested in since I was about sixteen. It was super tiring- there were hardly ANY places to sit. It was also the hottest weekend in Tokyo, over 40 degrees. It was too hot for me to even put on my cosplay. Not exaggeration, I couldn’t apply make-up without it dripping off. My shorts and t-shirt were drenched. I, like many others, wore a towel around my neck and constantly used a fan. Kudos to those who cosplayed, but it wasn’t worth my health.
The vending machines were also constantly queued up (about 50 people at a time) and kept running out.
It was interesting, but not one I would do again and definitely a disappointment in many aspects. Where were the famous voice actors, official merch and cosplay shows/skits?
Again, it may be due to my lack of Japanese ability, but I doubt it.
In contrast, I attended the MCM Glasgow Con this weekend. After Comiket, my expectations were pretty low. MCM restored my faith in everything a con could be.
Firstly, the reception in Glasgow itself was amazing. The guy in the City Parking was a sweetie, helping me with the machine and guiding me to the right door. Construction men (who I expected abuse from) told me happily I was the best costume they’d seen yet and to enjoy my day. Later on at McDonalds, no one gave me abuse and the worker behind the till was genuinely interested what I was wearing and why.
We had brought early entry tickets, but even then the queue was massive. I was so happy at the turn out and all the amazing cosplays.
Which brings me to issue four. People assume it’s so easy to access everything for cosplay in Japan- true if you live in Tokyo and have a good grasp of the language. The costume I wanted came from a Japanese site, but turned out to be from China. My wig was also from China. I couldn’t locate the socks anywhere and finally got a pair from ebay upon my return.
I found it incredibly difficult to locate the simplest things. Buying online was also faced with nightmares of filling in forms using google translate, and the post office always delivering when I was out/ unable to find my apartment.
Actually in the UK, we have access to so many amazing cosplay sites, as well as local companies that do commissions for wigs, props etc. You can buy pretty much everything from ebay. We are actually in a much better position here than I was in Japan, where the only advantage was being closer to China (yet a lot of ebay companies wouldn’t ship to Japan).
Back to MCM! There were a lot of complaints about the queues, but I don’t think the staff had been prepared for such as massive turnout- the estimated 10,000 doubled to 20,000 attendees. We were lucky we arrived at the right time- I heard many tales from friends of two hours queues and people giving up. But being able to walk in with cosplay on felt AMAZINNNNG.
We had a few hiccups at the start of the day. The SECC was holding another conference (they won’t make that mistake next year!) so we weren’t allowed to use the cloakroom (though the girl was very apologetic).
We decided to go dump stuff in my car. I asked one of the staff if it was okay to go out the side door, since we had been stamped. He said that was fine. However, I double checked with another guy as we left the actual doors and he promptly told us we wouldn’t be getting back in.
To quote, he said “this is what we want to avoid”. Aka, people walking about in costumes while important officials were in town. He was the only rude guy we encountered. I informed the first guy, not only because of the way we were treated, but also because I didn’t want anyone else being refused back in.
This was a tiny spot on what was an amazing day. Although only one hall, the place was packed with merch- posters, DVDs, plushies, clothes, wigs etc. It was the kind of con I had always imagined but had given up ever experiencing.
The products are always marked up and I never buy what I can get cheaper online, but it’s simply amazing to see the stuff on display and watch your fellow fans get excited about them.
The biggest thing for me was the fact Vic Mignogna had his own booth and would be giving a talk. It was an okay system- you received a raffle ticket and had to keep checking back for your number zone.
We wandered around the stalls and were able to find places to sit and eat. It was hot and busy, but thankfully not as bad smelling as some UK cons can get (sorry, it’s true).
It was a dream come true to meet Vic. The conversation (while he signed the free Edward Elric poster) went like:
Vic: “Wow, I love your costume!”
Me: “Eeee…I love you, Vic!”
Vic: “I love you, too! Let’s run away together!”
Me: “Eeeeee. Can we get a picture?”
Vic: “Sure!!” *big hugs* “You smell great!”
Me: *shaking*
“I’m going to come to your talk!”
Vic: “Great, see you then!”
Had to record that so I won’t ever forget it ^^
After a bit of looking around the stalls, we settled down for the talks. There were Q&A’s for Warwick Davis, two stars from Merlin, and many others. However most of us were there for Vic ^^
He was fantastic as always, really connecting with the fans and making everyone laugh. He also treated us with some lines- Edward Elric saying “good things come in small packages!” and Tamaki’s coffee line (delivered to a girl who nearly passed out). He also got everyone to sing happy birthday to one lucky girl!
By then some of my friends were ready to go home. It was busy throughout the day, as bursts of people left and came in. The word was already spreading that next year the con would take place over 2 days and be more spread out.
I bought a Happy plushie to go with my Lucy Heartfilia, not too expensive at £15.
On the whole, the MCM con was a much more pleasant and fulfilling experience than Comiket. To those who plan to go to Japan for anime conventions alone, this is my advice- stay at home. Spend your money on better costumes and travelling to the many conventions we have in the UK. If you wanted to, I reckon you could attend a different con every month. I was in Japan for a year, and I cosplayed twice. I attended one official con.
If you want to go to Japan, go for the culture, the history, the beautiful scenery, the food, the amazing people, and the many other awesome things.
For places to go, check my other blogs 😉
BBC’s article on the MCM Scotland Expo- http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-24003010
Hope this was informative!